Showing posts with label section-097-appointment-of-rp. Show all posts
Showing posts with label section-097-appointment-of-rp. Show all posts

Thursday, 5 May 2022

Rajesh Kumar Sinha Vs. Apogee Enterprises Pvt. Ltd. - The fees of the Resolution Professional must be commensurate to and be a reasonable compensation of the amount of work involved.

NCLT New Delhi-VI (01.04.2022) in Rajesh Kumar Sinha  Vs. Apogee Enterprises Pvt. Ltd.   [IA-457/2021 IN IB-514/ND/2020  ] held that;

  • As we have not come across enabling provision with regard to fixation of the fee of IRP in matters pertaining to initiation  of proceeding under Section 95 of IBC wherein fees/expenses  were not fixed by the financial creditor, 

  • We therefore have  drawn analogy from Regulation 33(2) of the Insolvency and  Bankruptcy Board of India (Insolvency Resolution Process  for Corporate Persons) Regulations, 2016. 

  • The fees of the Resolution  Professional must be  commensurate to and be a reasonable compensation of the  amount of work involved.


Excerpts of the order;

# 1. The present application  is filed by the Resolution  Professional, Mr. Rajesh Kumar Sinha, for issue of directions  to the Creditor to pay the remuneration of the Resolution  Professional on 16.01.2021. This is a case wherein the  Creditor has filed application under Section 95 by itself and  not through the Resolution Professional. In exercise of  powers conferred under sub-section 3 of Section 97, the IBBI  has nominated the Resolution Professional for carrying out  the Insolvency Resolution Process by its letter/file no: IP  13011/1/2019-IBBI/884/250 dated 05-03-2020. 

 

# 2. The creditor has filed a detailed reply on 04.01.2022  disputing the remuneration claimed by the IRP.  

 

# 3. We have gone through the application and reply filed in this  matter. The arguments advanced by the counsels for both  the parties and written submissions have been considered.  To be precise and concise and to ensure brevity, those  submissions have not been reproduced here. It transpires  that there was not any prior consensus or any formal  understanding amongst the parties regarding fees and  expenses of the RP. This Tribunal is of view that the Creditor  i.e., Apogee Enterprises Pvt. Ltd should have fixed the fees of  the IRP/RP clearly and amicably well in advance or prior to  the commencement of the work by IRP. 

 

# 4. During the proceedings, both the parties have submitted that  this tribunal may decide the fees and they have also  consented to abide by the order of this tribunal. 

 

# 5. We have examined the question of whether the Adjudicating  Authority can determine the fees payable to the Resolution  Professional in case the fee/expenses of the Resolution  Professional have not been fixed/determined by the Financial Creditor/Applicant. 

 

# 6. As we have not come across enabling provision with regard to fixation of the fee of IRP in matters pertaining to initiation  of proceeding under Section 95 of IBC wherein fees/expenses  were not fixed by the financial creditor, we therefore have  drawn analogy from Regulation 33(2) of the Insolvency and  Bankruptcy Board of India (Insolvency Resolution Process  for Corporate Persons) Regulations, 2016. The said sub  regulation 2 of regulation 33 enables the Adjudicating  Authority to determine the fees of the IRP in case the same  is not fixed by the applicant.  Taking spirit of law from above, this Adjudicating Authority is of the view that it may decide the  remuneration/expenses of the IRP/RP specially when these  expenses/fees  were  not  fixed  in  advance  by  applicant/creditor. 

 

# 7. The fees of the Resolution  Professional must be  commensurate to and be a reasonable compensation of the  amount of work involved, we hereby fix the fees of the  Resolution Professional, as per the details given below: 

  • i. Fees for the initial period 31st Aug 2020 to 14th Oct 2020:  Rs 3,50,000 per month as against the fees claimed by the  RP of Rs.4,50,000 per month. While determining the fees  for this period, we have duly taken into account the  various steps involved prior to submission of report as per  the provisions of the IBC, 2016. 

  • ii.  Fees for the period w.e.f. 15th October, 2020 till the date of  compliance of this order: Rs. 50,000 per month as against  the fees claimed by the RP of Rs.1,00,000 per month. While  determining the fees of this period, we have considered the  fact of adjournment of the matter and also the quantum of  litigations managed/work performed by the Resolution  Professional before the Honble Supreme Court of India  and also before this Tribunal. 

  • iii. All other expenses such as Counsel fees and Out of Pocket  expenses (as provided by the Resolution Professional in its   ‘Calculation Statement of Fees) are not unreasonable  considering the continuous involvement of the RP in the  matter. 

 

# 8. Creditor is directed to comply with this order within 10 days  and the compliance affidavit of this order may be filed before  this tribunal at the earliest. 

 

# 9. We further direct Registry NCLT, New Delhi to forward a copy  of this order to IBBI to look into the aspect of fixation of fee  of the IRP/RP in matters relating to personal guarantees and  to make/incorporate suitable regulation in the existing  regulations on 'Insolvency Resolution Process for Personal  Guarantors to Corporate Debtors' Regulations, 2019 so as to  reduce and rule-out the scope of litigation by the Creditor  and Resolution Professional. IBBI may also consider to draw  analogy from Sub-regulation (1) and (2) of Regulation 33 of  IBBI (Insolvency Resolution Process of Corporate Persons)  Regulations, 2016. 

 

# 10. The IA No. 457/ND/2021 in IB-514/ND/2020 stands  disposed of. 

 

----------------------------------------------


Thursday, 25 November 2021

L. Ramalakshmamma & Anr. Vs. State Bank of India. - On going through word ‘shall’ occurred in Section 97(1) of ‘IBC’ employed in Section 97(1) of ‘IBC’, this ‘Tribunal’ is of the considered view that it is only ‘Directory’ and not ‘Mandatory’ and holds it so.

NCLAT(22.11.2021) In L. Ramalakshmamma & Anr. Vs. State Bank of India. [Company Appeal(AT)(CH)(Insolvency) No. 220 & 221 of 2021] held that; - 

  • # 32. A ‘Resolution Professional’ is an indispensable person in ‘Insolvency Resolution Process’, as he has a pivotal part to play. No wonder, an ‘Adjudicating Authority’ can exercise his judicial discretion in appointing a ‘Resolution Professional’ in a given case, based on the facts and circumstances of the case, which float on the surface.

  • # 33. Moreover, if viewed from the object and purpose to be achieved by ‘IBC’, the word employed in Section 97(1) “shall” can only be construed as ‘directory’ by any stretch of imagination and not a mandatory one, that too by adopting a purposeful, meaningful, practical, pragmatic and result oriented approach, with a view to prevent an aberration of justice and to secure the ends of justice.

  • # 34. In the instant case on hand, on going through word ‘shall’ occurred in Section 97(1) of ‘IBC’ employed in Section 97(1) of ‘IBC’, this ‘Tribunal’ is of the considered view that it is only ‘Directory’ and not ‘Mandatory’ and holds it so,

 

Excerpts of the order;

# 2. The ‘Adjudicating Authority’ had passed the ‘Impugned Orders’ dated 23.07.2021 in I.A.(IBC) No. 346 of 2021 CP(IB) No. 02/95/HDB/2021 and I.A.(IBC) No. 347 of 2021 in CP(IB) No. 03/95/HDB/2021 whereby and whereunder he had appointed Mr. Anil Kohli as an ‘Interim Resolution Professional’ and directed him to file report under Section 90 of IBC, within 5th days from the date of his appointment etc. 

 

# 5. It is represented on behalf of the Appellants that the ‘Adjudicating Authority’ on 27.08.2018 passed an order for liquidation of Lanco Infratech Ltd and because of the reason that no Resolution Plan was approved by the ‘Committee of Creditors’ (in short ‘CoC’), Mr. Savan Godiavala was appointed as ‘Liquidator’.

 

#7. The Learned Counsel for the Appellants points out that in the year 2021, the First Respondent filed Company Petition No. 03/95/MDB/2021 as per Section 95 of ‘IBC’ against the Appellants before the ‘Adjudicating Authority’ and that on 31.05.2021, the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India had upheld the validity of the Rules. Moreover, through an order dated 23.07.2021, the ‘Adjudicating Authority’ had allowed the Application filed by the First Respondent for ‘Urgent Hearing’ and listed the matters for ‘Hearing’ on the same day. In fact, the ‘Adjudicating Authority’ by the ‘‘Impugned Orders’’’ had appointed Mr. Anil Kohli as the ‘IRP’ without adhering to the mandatory Section 97 of ‘IBC’.

 

# 8. The Learned Counsel for the Appellants contends that Section 95(1) of the ‘IBC’ enjoins that a Creditor may, either by himself or through a Resolution Professional file an Application for initiating ‘Insolvency Resolution Process’ against the ‘Personal Guarantor’ or a Partnership Firm. Also, that it is the stand of the Appellants that even Application under Section 95 of ‘IBC’ is filed through Resolution Professional, as in the instant case, then Section 97(1) & (2) of the ‘IBC’ can get attracted.

 

# 10. The Learned Counsel for the Appellants adverts to Rule 8(1) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy (Application to ‘Adjudicating Authority’ for Insolvency Resolution Process for Personal Guarantors to Corporate Debtors) Rules, 2019 which provides that for the purposes of sub-Section (2) of Section 97 and sub-Section (5) of Section 97. The Board may share the database of the ‘Insolvency Professional’s including the information about disciplinary proceedings against them with the ‘Adjudicating Authority’ from time to time and that the ‘Adjudicating Authority’ shall accordingly pass an order in terms of Section 97(5) of ‘IBC’.

 

# 11. The stand of the Appellants is that the ‘IBC’ 2016 provides that appointment of the ‘IRP’ under Section 97(5) of IBC requires mandatory compliance of Sections 97(1) and 97(2) of IBC read with Rule 8 of Insolvency and Bankruptcy (Application to Adjudicating Authority for Insolvency Resolution Process for Personal Guarantors to Corporate Debtors) Rules, 2019. Clearly, before ‘IRP’ being appointed the same was to seek confirmation from the IBBI that no disciplinary proceedings are against him. However, in the instant case, the ‘Impugned Orders’ are completely silent as to whether the ‘Adjudicating Authority’ was in receipt of communication issued by the IBBI confirming the appointment of the ‘IRP’ under Section 97 of ‘IBC’ or in receipt of any database to confirm that no disciplinary proceedings are pending against the ‘IRP’ under Rule 8 of Insolvency and Bankruptcy (Application to Adjudicating Authority for Insolvency Resolution Process for Personal Guarantors to Corporate Debtors) Rules, 2019. Besides this, the ‘Impugned Orders’ had relied on 96(1)(a) of “IBC’ and that the ‘Adjudicating Authority’ had appointed Mr. Anil Kohli as the ‘IRP’.

 

# 12. The prime submission of the Learned Counsel of the Appellants is that the word ‘shall’ has been employed in Section 97 of ‘IBC’ is a mandatory character of the legislative intent and in short Sections 97(1) & 97(2) of ‘IBC’ are mandatory pre-condition which ought to be satisfied before the ‘Adjudicating Authority’ can proceed to pass order under Section 97(5) of ‘IBC’.

 

# 13. The Learned Counsel for the Appellants comes out with the plea that when a statute prescribes certain formalities to be complied with, those prescribed formalities are very much essential to do something which is mandatory in nature and the same cannot be simply ignored or given a goby in haste and in this connection the Learned Counsel for the Appellants places reliance on the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the matter of ‘The State of Haryana and Anr. Versus Raghubir Das’ reported in (1) (1995)1SCC 133 and in ‘Mohan Singh & Ors. Vs. International Airport Authority’ in (1997) 9 SCC 132.

 

# 14. The Learned Counsel for the Appellants takes a state that without determining the aspect of non-compliance of Section 97 of ‘IBC’, any determination under Section 100 of ‘IBC’ shall affect the vital rights of the Appellants. That apart, the Learned Counsel for the Appellants submits that the ‘IBC’ is a complete, exhaustive and inclusive Code and any deviation from the prescribed procedure would defeat the intent and purposes of the Code and refers to the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in ‘M/s Innoventive Industries Ltd. Vs. ICICI Bank & Anr.’ Reported in AIR 2017 SC 4084 and ‘M/s Embassy Property Developers Pvt. Ltd. Vs. State of Karnataka’ reported in (2020) 13 SCC 308.

 

# 19 The Learned Counsel for the Respondents by placing reliance on the Judgment of this ‘Tribunal’ in ‘Mr. Ravi Ajit Kulkarnis Vs. State Bank India’ vide Company Appeal (AT)(Insolvency) No. 316 of 2021 contends that the provisions of Sections 97(1) & 97(2) of ‘IBC’ whereby the ‘Adjudicating Authority’ is required to confirm the Board before appointing ‘Resolution Professional’ is directory in nature and the same is not mandatory one. Moreover, the Rule 8(1) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy (Application to Adjudicating Authority for Insolvency Resolution Process for Personal Guarantors to Corporate Debtors) Rules, 2019 specifically mentions that the Board may provide the ‘Adjudicating Authority’ the database containing the requisite details of ‘Resolution Professional’ to enable the ‘Adjudicating Authority’ to appoint ‘Resolution Professional’ in a timely manner to further the objects of ‘IBC’.

  

# 23. The Learned Counsel for the Respondents contends that the use of the word ‘shall’ under Section 97 of ‘IBC’ is directory and not mandatory and call for substantial and not rigid interpretation as used in Section 97 of “IBC’. In this regard, the Learned Counsel for the Respondent adverts to the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in “Kailash Vs. Nanhku & Ors.” reported in (2005) 4 SCC 480 wherein in paragraph-8 it is observed as under:

  • “All the rules of procedure are the handmaid of justice. The language employed by the draftsman of processual law may be liberal and stringent, but the fact remains that the object of prescribing procedure is to advance the cause of justice. In an adversarial system, no party should ordinarily be denied the opportunity of participating in the process of justice dispensation. Unless compelled by express and specific language of the Statute, the provisions of the CPC or any other procedural enactment ought not to be construed in a manner which would leave the court helpless to meet extraordinary situations in the ends of justice.”

 

# 24. The Learned Counsel for the Respondents submits that where the expression ‘shall’ has been used it would not necessarily mean that it is mandatory and it will always depend upon the facts of the given case. The conjoint reading of relevant provision together with other provisions of the Rules, the purposes sought to be achieved and the object beginning implementation of such a provision as per decision in ‘Dinesh Chandra Pandey Vs. High Court of M.P. & Anr.’ Reported in (2010) 11 SCC 500.

 

# 25. The Learned Counsel for the Respondents contends that ‘time is the essence of the Code’ and further that the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the decision of ‘Mohan Singh & Ors. Vs. International Airport Authority’ in (1997) 9 SCC 132 has observed and held that the Court is required to keep in view the impact of the Professional necessity of its compliance if the word ‘shall’ is considered as having mandatory character, the mischief that would ensure by such construction.

 

# 32. A ‘Resolution Professional’ is an indispensable person in ‘Insolvency Resolution Process’, as he has a pivotal part to play. No wonder, an ‘Adjudicating Authority’ can exercise his judicial discretion in appointing a ‘Resolution Professional’ in a given case, based on the facts and circumstances of the case, which float on the surface.

 

# 33. Moreover, if viewed from the object and purpose to be achieved by ‘IBC’, the word employed in Section 97(1) “shall” can only be construed as ‘directory’ by any stretch of imagination and not a mandatory one, that too by adopting a purposeful, meaningful, practical, pragmatic and result oriented approach, with a view to prevent an aberration of justice and to secure the ends of justice.

 

# 34. In the instant case on hand, ongoing through word ‘shall’ occurred in Section 97(1) of ‘IBC’ employed in Section 97(1) of ‘IBC’, this ‘Tribunal’ is of the considered view that it is only ‘Directory’ and not ‘Mandatory’ and holds it so, in the teeth of Rule 8(1) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy (Application to ‘Adjudicating Authority’ for Insolvency Resolution Process for Personal Guarantors to Corporate Debtors) Rules, 2019 and also by which the NCLT may pick up any one from the Panel for appointment of ‘IRP’ Liquidator, Resolution Professional and Bankruptcy Trustee. As such, when the ‘Adjudicating Authority’ had exercised its judicial discretion in fair manner for the appointment of Mr. Anil Kohli as an ‘IRP’, the same cannot be found fault with as opined by this ‘Tribunal’.

 

# 35. In view of the foregoings, the contra plea, taken on behalf of the Appellants that before passing of an order under Section 97(5) of ‘IBC’, the ingredients of sections 91 and 92 of ‘IBC’, are ought to be satisfied, is not acceded to by this ‘Tribunal’. Looking at from any angle, the ‘Impugned Orders’ dated 23.07.2021 in I.A.(IBC) No. 346 of 2021 CP(IB) No. 02/95/HDB/2021 and I.A.(IBC) No. 347 of 2021 in CP(IB) No. 03/95/HDB/2021 for appointment of Mr. Anil Kohli as ‘IRP’ and directing him to file ‘Report’ under Section 99(1)) of ‘IBC’ are free from any legal patent legal errors. Hence, the ‘Appeals’ fail.

 

------------------------------------------------------